Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Social Commentary in Literature

Katherine Brideau
Ms. Alchorn
English 111
18 December, 2010
The Great Gatsby: F. Scott Fitzgerald’s Debasement of The American Dream
On the surface, The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a story of a man’s pursuit for his dream woman. However, the main theme of the novel is much less romantic. The Great Gatsby is in essence a social commentary on the Roaring Twenties, better known as the period where the American Dream became a reality full of promise and prosperity. In this novel, Fitzgerald explores the whirlwind pace of this era through class conflict, cultural rifts between East and West and how significant wealth was when it came to fulfilling the American Dream.
In The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald portrays the post-World War I American Dream as corrupted. Instead of making it stand for independence and the ability to make something out of hard work and the aftermaths of war, the American Dream is rather portrayed as materialism at best with underlying tones of selfish pursuit of pleasure. Fitzgerald also indicates that hard work and merit are not enough for when it comes to characters such as Gatsby no amount of effort or money can change where he came from thus once again illustrating the superiority associated to people with old money. This is further highlighted through Nick’s upbringing in a “prominent, well-to-do people [in this Middle Western city] for three generations” (1.5) family , he has had a comfortable life but he has not lived the luxurious existence the Bunchanans have, even though his family has lived the American Dream by doing hard work to get them their wealth.
The American Dream in The Great Gatsby is represented mostly through social class. In the very opening of this novel, Nick, the narrator is quoted saying “In my younger and more vulnerable years my father gave me some advice that I’ve been turning over in my mind ever since. “Whenever you feel like criticizing any one” he told me, “just remember that all the people in this world haven’t had the advantages that you’ve had” (1.1-3) The rich, the poor and everyone present in the book are identified by how much money they have. Fitzgerald sculpts characters with unimaginable amounts of money such as the Bunchanans, characters of upper-middle-class origins such as Nick, woking-class characters such as Wilson and wealthy characters that are still look down upon by those with old money such as Gatsby, all in the goal of focusing on a developing New York City and its suburbs, where all of the classes are pitted very closely together.
It is important to note that Fitzgerald clearly establishes that wealth can be distinguished from class. While it is possibly to achieve great wealth without acceptance within the elite class, poverty restricts decision and action in The Great Gatsby. The novels two main locations, West Egg and East Egg, are not only distinguished by class, but also by wealth. East Egg represents “old money” whereas West Egg represents new money. However, characters who live in East Egg, notably the Bunchanans, consistently look down on characters that live in West Egg. However, residents of West Egg such as Nick simply note that he “[I] lived at West Egg, the – well, the least fashionable of the two” but that calling it least fashionable was “a most superficial tag to express the bizarre and not a little sinister constrast between them” (1.14) while outsiders such as the Wilsons yearn to “go West” but are unable to due to a lack of money, therefore contrasting different idealisms behind the definition of wealth and the American Dream.
While Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby offers up a peek into American life in the 1920’s, the underlying commentary on social class, wealth and the corruption of the American Dream through greed and power embodied by Fitzgerald reveal the most prevalent characteristics and attitudes during this period. As a whole, Ftizgerald’s Gatsby establishes that dreams, hard work and merit aren’t always enough in a world run by the elite.

1 comment: